Viewers Rate NYC Bars
"The collective knowledge of some of NY's most prolific bar flies"
To submit a rating of a New York bar, click here
Note: The opinions expressed are those of individual surveyors, and are not necessarily the opinions of MurphGuide Entertainment

Listed Alphabetically: This Page: I

A - B - C - D - E - F - G - H - I - J - K - L - M - N - O - P - Q - R - S - T - U - V - W - X - Y - Z

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
Idlewild
(Avg. of 2 reviews)
145 E. Houston St. (at Eldridge) 7.5 8.5 7.5 10

Comments - Looks like the inside of an airplane. D.L.

Good on Wednesday. Sick music. - C.
Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
Iguana
(Avg. of 3 reviews)
240 W. 54th St. (between Broadway & 8th Ave.) 8.7 8.3 7.3 10

Comments - Iguanas is a definite hot spot. Restaurant is absolutely beautiful and romantic and they serve Mexican food that is delicious! The club downstairs opens at 6:30pm and the DJ spins music starting from the 70's and up. After work crowd, 20-30 something crowd. It's hot on Thursday's and Friday's. Check it out. I give this place 10's a cross the board! - J.T.

Had to take issue with the 10 for service on the previous review. Been there plenty of times on Thursday, a big night for them, and the bartenders have no problem making you wait twenty or so minutes for a drink. - J.M.

Was there on a Thursday night a year ago and then went again a few Thursdays ago. I have to say the music has gotten a lot better as well as the crowd! The DJ was on point playing a good mix of dance, hip hop, R&B with some Spanish music too. The drinks are great, the bartenders are definitely not stingy on the alcohol! - S.Y.
Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
Iggy's
(Avg. of 3 reviews)
1452 Second Ave. (between 75th & 76th St.) 7.3 6.0 8.3 5.3

Comments - Great renovations in my favorite bar. It's fantastic. - P.

The karaoke in this bar rocks. Great time, every time. Great pool table. Check it out, well worth it. - S.P.

Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
Iggy's Keltic Lounge
(Avg. of 2 reviews)
132 Ludlow St. (between Stanton & Rivington St.) 9.0 9.5 9.0 8.0

Comments This is the best bar downtown by far. -S.W.

I go to the other Iggy's uptown. and I love it. but I have got to tell you to check out this place.  Great ambiance, great design and what a juke box, smashing. To tell you of all the beautiful girls that were there would take all night, so I'll just let you all check it out. The bar staff are cool cats. Once again, well done Iggy. -P.W.
Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
The Inn (Long Island)
(Avg. of 6 reviews)
943 West Beech Street, Long Beach NY 8.2 8.8 7.8 8.3

Comments - The "new and improved" Inn is a definite good time. DJ Timmy Tunes plays great drinking music---good for a fun dance floor and for people who want to stand around the top and enjoy watching the bar below. The bands so far have matched Tim's music. The crowd is a great mix--equal ratio men to women and ages ranging between 21-35. Everyone is having a good time! - J.M.R.

It's owned by the same people who own CJ Sullivan's in Bayside and the Publick House in Southampton. Well lit, there are two bars (a large one and a small one in the back), a stage, a dance floor, and a mezzanine. The music (live acts most nights) seems to resound off the high ceiling. There seems to be a golf theme to the decor. It's very popular (crowded) drawing a good twentysomething and thirtysomething clientele. Very often, there is "no room at the Inn". It features a jukebox, several TVs, and a good pub menu. They take away the barstools when it starts to get crowded. The bathrooms have lines when the joint is crowded. - T.K.

Worth stopping in and staying. Good music - whether band or DJ, Nice crowd, polite doormen, and well done interior. - D.A.

While the old Inn may have been worse for wear in the last couple of years, at least it had context and character. While the siding may have been cheap and the interior drab the staff were great and the bar fit the West End like a hand fits the glove. The same can't be said of its stone veneer replacement which while immaculate seems more suited for the Hudson Valley. Furthermore, the spaced-out bar maids need to lay-off the disco biscuits. - D.M.

The Inn is one of the hottest places to go to right now. They have a great DJ who plays a variety of music. They also have awesome bands who know how to play to the crowd. The staff is so much fun. The female bartenders not only know how to serve the drinks, but they know how to dance, especially on the bar at 4 in the morning. So to the critic above who told them to lay off the disco biscuits, I note a bit of jealously. Nobody seems to mind their bartending/dancing talent, including the girls who come to the bar. The place is still packed at last call, so you know they are doing something right. - A.D.

The new Inn is a great place to see a live band due to the fact that the sound system is awesome. The sound system is at times too loud and you have to scream to hold a conversation and this is especially true when the band is on a break and the DJ is playing. The sound definitely is on the verge of being at a level that can cause deafness. I am a fan of loud music but this is at a whole different level. The way that the bar charges a cover you would think that is the only way that they can make money. I guess this is paying for the renovations or something. The bands are good and supposedly "expensive" but they are cover bands and decent at best. As far as the service I found it very easy to get drinks, however I was charged a different price each time. As a former bartender I understand that there are different prices at different times of the day, but I have only been to the Inn after midnight so it must be a new system. The chances of getting a buyback are near impossible, yet the bartender patiently awaits their tip when the drinks are served. Overall, I had a good time at the bar, although I was disappointed at having to pay city prices in Long Beach without getting the city services or atmosphere. The only city aspect was the politeness of the doorman and the girls dancing on the bar. - B.G.

Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
International Bar
(Avg. of 2 reviews)
120 First Ave. (between 7th & 8th St.) 5.5 5.0 7.5 4.0

Comments - I have no idea what the name of this small, narrow dive bar is supposed to mean. It doesn't seem to draw many patrons. It has no TV, a jukebox with a sign on it reading "play at your own risk", a bookcase, a low ceiling with fans, brick walls, cocktail tables, Christmas lights up all year round, and a small backyard. The beer selection is somewhat limited. The prices are reasonable and the service is decent. The one-at-a-time bathrooms are atrocious (the sinks are outside). - T.K.

Just what you would expect from an East Village dive: a dark, narrow bar with cheap drinks, eclectic decor and a hip local crowd. Check out the vintage photos on the wall. Also has outside seating in backyard. - S.M.
Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
The Irish Pub
(Avg. of 4 reviews)
839 Seventh Ave. (between 53rd & 54th St.) 6.8 6.3 7.3 6.0

Comments - A good place to start an evening. It has a decent selection of brews and the place was filling up with people even though it wasn't even the weekend yet. Prices were reasonable too. - O.K.

A lively, upbeat pub that draws both New Yorkers and tourists. Friendly and efficient Irish bartenders.  Reasonable prices. Good food at decent prices. High top bar tables. TV, large picture window. Interesting map of Ireland/families coats of arms in the basement. Bathrooms are adequate but are located in the basement. - T.K.

Nice little place for a mid-town tourist/theatre crowd place. Real Irish barkeeps, some good beer selection and every fourth draught on the house make it a nice place to start an evening or have a relaxing drink after work. - A.S.

Nice bar, but no buy backs. Besides that, it went well. - L.C.
Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
The Irish Rover
(Avg. of 4 reviews)
37-18 28th Ave. (corner of 38th St.), Astoria, Queens 9.3 6.5 9.5 5.0

Comments - The barmen are the best in NYC! Never leave you waiting! - T.R.

The best Guinness in New York City and a crowd that's as friendly as any in the world. Got to go and check it out. - K.B.

Always full of people and fun. Everyone is there to have a good time and meet new people. There is always a decent band on Saturdays and the bartenders are the best! - K.Z.

Has one big screen and a few smaller screen TVs for watching "the game". Usually has a good band on Saturday nights. The Guinness is excellent and the people and staff are friendly and attentive. - B.C.
Add your review

Bar Address Atmosphere Decor Service Bathroom
Irving Plaza 17 Irving Place (between 15th & 16th St.) 8 9 7 7

Comments - Irving Plaza is an old ball-room style place that is primarily used as a live music venue (also hosts swing dancing on Sunday nights).  It presents medium sized rock acts like Billy Bragg, Dar Williams, They Might Be Giants, Jeff Tweedy, etc. The first floor houses the box office, coat check, restrooms and a small lounge area. The main room sits on the second floor, with a large stage, dance-floor and bar.  The third floor acts as a terrace over the dance-floor. Located in the Gramercy area of Manhattan, it is one of the top places to see a band in NYC. - S.M.
Add your review

A - B - C - D - E - F - G - H - I - J - K - L - M - N - O - P - Q - R - S - T - U - V - W - X - Y - Z


Don't just read them, send one in!

Click here to add your own reviews...

What goes on...
Main Page Upcoming Events Daily Specials Happy Hour Join Mailing List
Features...
Joke of the Day Overheard at... Bar Reviews Bar Survey Links
Bar of the Week Notes from
the Field
Articles MurphGuide
Sports column
Kimberly's
Music Column
Shots!
(Party Photos)
Shot of the Day Shop on Line Feedback Hot Spots
Special Bar Interests...
Bar Links Beer Lovers Brew Pubs Cigar Bars Comedy Clubs
Dance Clubs Don't Go There...
(closed bars)
Guest Bartending Irish Bars Jazz Clubs
Karaoke Nights Live Music Lounges Mexican Bars New Bars
Outdoor Drinking Poetry Readings Romantic Spots Saloons Singles
Sports Bars Summer 
Beach Bars
Swing Nights Tapas Bars Wine Bars